Saturday, March 08, 2014

Further response to Dr. Jerrold Atlas

Atlas adds:
Dear Suzarin raises some important on-the-spot
comments about the changing climate in India.
It is a groundswell reaction to dissatisfaction with 
the ways things have not been going well in India.
Thus, Congress has lost the people's confidence --
as have the old concepts of Gandhi/Nehru based on
building a "civilized" India on the foundations set 
in the British rule.

I think much more discussion about this is essential 
to understanding India ahead.  It is a rejection of 
what had been the founding ideas -- never a mark of 
stability in a nation the size of India.  Size and 
incredible diversity really mark what others have 
preferred to see: a fantasy meme of a monolithic 
people. 

Size prevents a modicum of order and civility as 
barely contained rage from overcrowdedness 
imperils order. One simply can't find "space" in 
public space to achieve calm and escape crowds 
-- thus, isolation becomes a mark of status and  
wealth enabling order and calm in one's private 
isolation space.  But what do the billion+ others do?

Diversity is now an increasingly burdensome mark 
of the reality of India despite a long history of 
public education instilling whatever the accepted
homogenized group-illusion of India has developed.
Thus, identity-formations exist among many sub-
groups creating a rash of parties emphasizing 
whatever their base seeks. This inhibits unity and
an acceptable national group-illusion. 

Indeed, frustrated younger elements turn to chaos 
and fomenting troubles for the larger national 
group because of this.  Large political parties find 
themselves broadening their message to 
accommodate the sub-groups within and this 
waters down their impact and acceptability to 
others. One simply can't be all things to all sub-
groups and remain a viable message in a huge and
very diverse group.  Simpler, all-embracing virtues/
values need to become the messages sold by large 
parties.

The turn away from what was also means a turn to 
a nationalist Hindu fantasy embodied in one party 
and leader.  How this will turn out for India is 
anyone's guess but it will definitely bring a rise in 
influence of the puritanical.  Thus, this change is so 
far turning more to cleansing India than marrying 
the sub-groups.  It is "exclusivity" rather than 
"inclusivity" -- a nasty turn and certainly one where
hates are turned into allowed rage by Indian laws.

Suzarin is wrong, however, in denying "banned" as 
the correct expression for what is taking place (with 
Doniger's book and many other elements of life there).
That Penguin chose a business decision rather than 
intellectual reality is a mark of the savaging of what 
had been India's real past for a revisionist meme 
hardly in keeping with the greatness that was. True,
the settlement eliminated the "banning" but it was
really a caving in to "banning".

Suzarin is fully correct, however, in everything else.
This is a dangerous turn for India, it will gain little 
more than hatred unleashed, violence nascent, anger
for a nation that needs tolerance and inclusivity. India
will be wasting its vast intellectual/cultural heritage
in the pursuit of unleashed angers and repression in a 
regressive regime.  Things do not bode well.  Mark's
other illustration of this shows the spreading nature
of this passionate "exclusivity".    J ATLAS]

My response:
I agree that the effect of Penguin India’s out of court settlement with the petitioners is the same as banning. But in India, a distinction is usually made between challenging and banning. Banning has to be by the government, with or without a court order.

Doniger’s book was only challenged by a retired school teacher and five others in a civil suit filed before one of the Additional District Judges in New Delhi in 2011. They had also registered two criminal complaints before a police station in New Delhi in 2010 and 2013.

But on February 4, Penguin agreed to withdraw all the copies of the book from India within a period of six months. On February 10, the court accepted the agreement and dismissed the suit as withdrawn. Following that, the two criminal complaints also stood withdrawn.

Wikipedia has a list of the books ‘banned’ and the books ‘challenged but not banned’ in India till date. Please see the link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_books_banned_in_India

Some of the books on the list may really surprise you.

I also agree with the detailed observations about what is looming over contemporary India, threatening its very survival as a single state. But history seldom follows predictions! One factor that might change the course for the better is a movement, nascent though, led by Arvind Kejriwal. India watchers may take note of the name.

Suzarin

Friday, March 07, 2014

Wendy Doniger's Op-Ed in the NYT - A response to Dr. Jerrold Atlas' remark

Dr Jerrold Atlas posted the link to Dr. Wendy Doniger's Op-Ed on the Psychohistory-historical motivations forum with his comment:
[Worthy of interest, even if just for the rising tide of Hindu nationalism that is 
about to burst forth in a new leader once condemned by the US.  This is the 
India few wanted to see -- a deeply nationalist, revisionist, highly puritanical 
defenders of a group-illusion that never was.  It is undemocratic in leaning 
and very willing to condemn those who oppose them as "enemies". It 
condemns their vision of a purified society in a deep group-think and rejects 
what had been the Hinduism of yore.  Thus, the Nehru-orginated Congress 
Party has lost control over the hearts and minds of the majority in India.

We should try to remember that India is a mix of old and new with enormous 
corruption and shoddy workmanship as well.  It is a country where education 
is prized but business shrewdness is more preferred, along with cronyism.  
Thus, some succeed while others feel the sting of rejection and or losing to 
become rather outcasts in their own world.  Add in the demographic bulge 
making population swell enormously (like China), increase urban tensions, 
harbor desires for emotional outbursts as a way of relieving overcrowdedness-
caused stress, seek relief in Bollywood-style extravaganzas and allow an 
increase in fundamentalist groups demanding faith-based purity or 
erversions with religious context.  

That neighboring Pakistan is nuclear and sees all purpose as attacking larger 
India while Pakistan fundamentalism has led to civil wars between opposing 
religious fanatics, fanatical modernists seeking success through industrial 
opportunities misusing their fellow Pakistanis, westernized generals and their 
armies focused on maintaining balance in society and protecting the nuclear 
arsenal and the borders, ISI agencies playing all sides against each other 
and willingly confronting what they deem to be Pakistan's enemies while 
rewarding or dealing with enemies of neighbors (and keeping Afghanistan
weak, disorganized and confused).

This region is a powder-keg of trouble dangerously trying to not let anyone 
light a match.  All the while, they have to watch the East where larger 
neighbor China is going through growth spasms and currency. manipulation, 
generating endless billionaires annually and then seeing them collapse into 
corruption (dragging down many of the party's potential leaders with them).  
Their enemy neighbor is blustering for power and making demands on 
neighbors that now frightens many.

In this context, the censoring of this standard text on Hindu past and culture 
past is very clearly understandable, albeit disgusting.  It is an academic 
author's dream, to be banned and become a best seller.               J ATLAS]

This was my response:
 ‘Banned in Bangalore’ is a misleading title for Dr. Doniger’s NYT Op-Ed. She chose it to sync with the mid 19th – mid 20th century selling caption in the U.S., ‘Banned in Boston’.
I am from Bangalore. The book was not banned there. It was not banned anywhere in India. It was just withdrawn by its publisher–distributor, Penguin Books, with the offer to ‘pulp’ the remaining stock in an out of court settlement with the petitioner. The Indian blasphemy law is quite illiberal and sweeping, and Penguin obviously wanted to avoid an acrimonious litigation. I condemn both the blasphemy law and the pusillanimity of Penguin Books.
I have read the book. I found it has nothing much to commend and nothing much to condemn.
The problem with every discourse is the mismatch of perceptions. This problem is extremely acute in the case of Hinduism. In the first place, the word ‘Hinduism’ itself is a misnomer. It does not signify any comprehensive system of belief or practice, let alone a unified one. As Dr. Atlas has correctly pointed out, some “deeply nationalist, revisionist, highly puritanical defenders of a group-illusion that never was” are trying to give it a monolithic form, but in vain. It was partly because of this problem that the main Hindu political outfits are using the word ‘Hindutva’ (the state of being a Hindu) instead, which the Indian Supreme Court has glibly defined in one of its judgment as a “way of life”. Actually, it is not one way of life but many.
About the Hindus, Doniger gave her perception. If others had disagreement with it, they could have given their versions. But fundamentalism does not work that way, whether it is of the defenders of a certain point of view, or its detractors.
This April, India is going to the polls. Political atmosphere here is hyper charged. Doniger’s book became an issue also because of that. As an aside, I agree with Dr. Atlas that the dream of an academic author to become a best seller through controversy has come true in the case of Dr. Wendy Doniger. So far so good!
Suzarin    

Monday, February 17, 2014

One rich guy will own India one day. Then...



Reproducing a cartoon by Tom Tomorrow on the Psychohistory-Historical Motivations Forum, Jerrold Atlas noted that what was depicted in it had actually happened long ago in Argentina.  There, in a chain action, the ever-rising cost of electricity made it accessible to fewer and fewer people, who in larger and larger numbers illegally tapped into the power lines, which forced the electricity companies to raise the price of power higher and higher on the few who could afford it, and eventually, only one very rich person paid the bill for the whole country.

Dr. Atlas further noted: “Humor is a coping mechanism and also signals the group's sense of being screwed. It is a signal of the large frustration by the many against the few. It is a warning to the few and they respond in various ways to prevent themselves from losing power – ‘police armies’, slashing safety nets, ending help for the young/poor/sick/seniors/public employees/working-middle classes/rigging voting districts/denying voting rights/corrupting all governance systems/buying congress people and judges/controlling the media.  Oh wait, that's what they're doing right now.”

As is evident from the cartoon itself, it relates directly to the U.S. super-rich individuals and corporates. But it can be about India too. With a class of political leaders that is ready to crawl when asked by the moneyed masters only to bend running the show, we are moving along the same path.

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Hitler hated Jews? My head is spinning!


We are all used to historians changing the past. They could do it because they only create it! Through interpreting the 'records', they create 'evidence', From the 'evidence' thus created, they create the 'past'! No Gospel, no theologian, to my knowledge, has claimed that God could or would change what has already happened! But historians can! That is not a big deal, though. But, this is a more serious matter. They have brought to light a new record! Questions about interpretation, evidence and true past can wait. Is this record genuine?

According to a news report [http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/176781], Shimon Rahamim, an 'elderly Israeli', discovered an article in a Hebrew-language newspaper, Doar Hayom, dated August 8, 1924.

In the course of discussing Hitler's role as leader of the “nationalist Germans,” that article states that in an interview with a German publication, he had expressed “his warm feelings for the Jewish people.” It further says that Hitler had told the interviewer that all nations that had fallen in the past had suffered that fate because of their negative treatment of Jews. “He recommended that the entire world take stock” of their relations with the Jews, and adjust their behavior accordingly.

The given history of the context is that Hitler was in prison at the time, having been arrested the year before for attempting to start a rebellion in Munich, known as the “Beer Hall Putsch,”. He was sentenced to five years, but was released after only nine months, in December 1924.

Is this article authentic? Rahamim says yes, that it is indeed possible that Hitler did make those statements, "perhaps in order to impress upon the authorities that he had reformed." Hitler was writing his anti-Semitic manifesto, Mein Kampf, precisely at that time! Mein Kampf was published in 1925.

Rahamim has also this advice: "The Jews need to be very wary of those who claim to 'love' them.... If they could say this about Hitler, how much more careful must we be'!

Let the 'sacred' facts of history take care of themselves. What matters is the perception. Does this news bite wring familiar to those Indians who are holding their ears close to the not so distant 'past'?


Monday, January 27, 2014

Do we fear our own happiness?

We may feel jealous about others' happiness. But, do we fear our own happiness? Yes, say some recent studies. Here is the link to a report on that, which appeared first in Scientific American. It also features a quiz to measure individual's fear. A single quiz may not fit all heads. Still, one shot at it without trying to be too clever may not disappoint.

The main contention of the studies is that there is a co-relation between fear of happiness and mental illness. It does not, however, ignore the conditioning culture, religious beliefs or philosophical attitudes may have on groups and individuals. I would submit that age, as it advances, inhibits the capacity to break out into seamless joy. We are used to calling it 'wisdom'! May be, that too is a sign of mental illness!

The link is: http://www.salon.com/2014/01/27/are_you_afraid_of_happiness_take_the_quiz_partner/?source=newsletter

Thursday, January 23, 2014

Why does life exist, or, more pointedly, how did life come into existence?


How did life begin? Undoubtedly the most fascinating question one could ask as of the present. But a definitive answer any time soon is most unlikely. 
Reproduction of life naturally and even artificially is not a big deal, but creating still is! If only we could give life to a lump of inorganic matter, it might at least help imagine how life first appeared on this planet, assuming that we are speaking only of 'life' as we know it only on this planet. We will certainly still not know how the first life, the Eve, came into being. And the creationists will still argue that 'reproduction' is not the same as 'creation'. Best way to engage them would be to leave them alone, for, belief is not amenable to reason. 
However popular and persistent the creation myths be, we do have some sophisticated guesses about the origin of life, all of which, incidentally, swim alongside the theory of evolution. Almost all such origin narratives have a common plot - of life springing from a primordial soup after getting struck by a bolt of lightning and a more potent bolt of luck. But, departing from this common line of thinking, a 31-year-old physicist at MIT, Dr. Jeremy England, claims that he has found the underlying physics driving the origin and evolution of life in which luck had no role. He thinks that the origin and subsequent evolution of life followed from the fundamental laws of nature 'as unsurprisingly as rocks roll downhill'!

To quote Natalie Wolchover ('A New Physics Theory of Life', Quanta Magazine, January 22, 2014): "From the standpoint of physics, there is one essential difference between living things and inanimate clumps of carbon atoms: The former tend to be much better at capturing energy from their environment and dissipating that energy as heat. Jeremy England ... has derived a mathematical formula that he believes explains this capacity. The formula, based on established physics, indicates that when a group of atoms is driven by an external source of energy (like the sun or chemical fuel) and surrounded by a heat bath (like the ocean or atmosphere), it will often gradually restructure itself in order to dissipate increasingly more energy. This could mean that under certain conditions, matter inexorably acquires the key physical attribute associated with life."

Here is the link to Wolchover article: 
https://www.simonsfoundation.org/quanta/20140122-a-new-physics-theory-of-life/

Thursday, January 09, 2014

Here is a PEW survey Report about How people in Muslim countries prefer women to dress in public, JANUARY 8, 2014, in FACTANK
BY JACOB POUSHTER 

Here is the link if the accompanying charts need to be seen: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/08/what-is-appropriate-attire-for-women-in-muslim-countries/#utm_source=mostpopularft&utm_medium=internal&utm_campaign=PR

An important issue in the Muslim world is how women should dress in public. A recent survey from the University of Michigan’s Institute for Social Research conducted in seven Muslim-majority countries (Tunisia, Egypt, Iraq, Lebanon, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey), finds that most people prefer that a woman completely cover her hair, but not necessarily her face. Only in Turkey and Lebanon do more than one-in-four think it is appropriate for a woman to not cover her head at all in public.
The survey treated the question of women’s dress as a visual preference. Each respondent was given a card depicting six styles of women’s headdress and asked to choose the woman most appropriately outfitted for a public place. Although no labels were included on the card, the styles ranged from a fully-hooded burqa (woman #1) and niqab (#2) to the less conservative hijab (women #4 and #5). There was also the option of a woman wearing no head covering of any type.

Overall, most respondents say woman #4, whose hair and ears are completely covered by a white hijab, is the most appropriately dressed for public. This includes 57% in Tunisia, 52% in Egypt, 46% in Turkey and 44% in Iraq. In Iraq and Egypt, woman #3, whose hair and ears are covered by a more conservative black hijab, is the second most popular choice.
In Pakistan, there is an even split (31% vs. 32%) between woman #3 and woman #2, who is wearing a niqab that exposes only her eyes, while nearly a quarter (24%) choose woman #4. In Saudi Arabia, a 63%-majority prefer woman #2, while an additional 11% say that the burqa worn by woman #1 is the most appropriate style of public dress for women.

In several countries, substantial minorities say it is acceptable for a woman to not cover her hair in public. Roughly a third (32%) of Turks take this view, as do 15% of Tunisians. Nearly half (49%) in Lebanon also agree that it is acceptable for a woman to appear in public without a head covering, although this may partly reflect the fact that the sample in Lebanon was 27% Christian. 

Demographic information, including results by gender, were not included in the public release of this survey.

Even as publics in many of the surveyed countries express a clear reference for women to dress conservatively, many also say women should be able to decide for themselves what to wear. This attitude is most prevalent in Tunisia (56%), Turkey (52%) and Lebanon (49%) – all countries where substantial percentages are open to women not covering their heads in public. But nearly as many in Saudi Arabia (47%) also say a women should be free to choose how she dresses. Smaller, but sizable percentages agree in Iraq (27%), Pakistan (22%) and Egypt (14%). What the survey leaves unanswered is whether respondents think social or cultural norms will guide women in their choice to wear more conservative or less conservative attire in public.

I commented: It is not coincidental that Tunisia, Lebanon and Turkey prefer to give more freedom to women to choose the way they would want to dress. They lead the predominantly Muslim majority countries preferring lesser cover for the female figure.
Left to themselves, what women would intuitively prefer might not be hard to guess, But why? To make themselves physically more attractive to the other gender?
That the human males, generally physically stronger, prefer to own and control their females, as immediate mates (spouses) and as prospective mates of other males (daughters) is the common notion. But, who has the last laugh? If women are ordained by nature to be owned and controlled, why should they try to be attractive? What difference will it make, whether the moth is beautiful or ugly, if it is only to be consumed by the flame! Or, are they trying to outwit other women in becoming a more attractive property or slave?

Monday, January 06, 2014

'Because' is the word of the year because. Period!

American Dialect Society has chosen 'because' as the word of the year for 2013 from among an impressive list of words that included slash, selfie, Obamacare, bitcoin and twerk, because change!

At the latest meeting of the Society, 'because' polled 127 out of a total of 175, pipping 'slash' at the last post because new popularity!

The days of using 'because' with a comma immediately before and a comma immediately after, followed by a full clause, as in 'I am ranting, because, I am mad', or an 'of', as in 'you are raving because of (my) madness' are passe because casual online usage!

Ben Zimmer, Chairman of the Society's new words committee, has explained: “No longer does ‘because’ have to be followed by of or a full clause.... Now one often sees tersely worded rationales like ‘because science’ or ‘because reasons.’ You might not go to a party ‘because tired.’ As one supporter put it, ‘because’ should be word of the year ‘because useful!’ ”. Wow! No wonder! The Dialect Society has voted 'because' as also the most useful word of the year. 

The leaders of some of the other word categories for 2013 are: 'catfish' (to misrepresent oneself online, especially as part of a romantic deception) in "Most Creative"; 'sharknado' (a tornado full of sharks as in the movie of that name) in "Most Unnecessary"; 'underbutt' (the underside of buttocks left visible by some shorts) in "Most Outrageous"; and 'least untruthful' (meaning the smallest necessary lie, used by the U.S. intelligence director James Clapper) in "Most Euphemistic".

The Society has been doing this ever since 1990 because? 

Saturday, December 28, 2013

Narendra Modi tweets about Gujarat riots that he Was wracked with pain

For the record, here is the full tweet, courtesy Forward Post:

My dear sisters and brothers, The law of nature is that Truth alone triumphs – Satyameva Jayate. Our judiciary having spoken, I felt it important to share my inner thoughts and feelings with the nation at large.

The end brings back memories of the beginning. The devastating earthquake of 2001 had plunged Gujarat into the gloom of death, destruction and sheer helplessness. Hundreds of lives were lost. Lakhs were rendered homeless. Entire livelihoods were destroyed. In such traumatic times of unimaginable suffering, I was given the responsibility to soothe and rebuild. And we had whole heartedly plunged ourselves into the challenge at hand.

Within a mere five months however, the mindless violence of 2002 had dealt us another unexpected blow. Innocents were killed. Families rendered helpless. Property built through years of toil destroyed. Still struggling to get back on its feet from the natural devastation, this was a crippling blow to an already shattered and hurting Gujarat.

I was shaken to the core. ‘Grief’, ‘Sadness’, ‘Misery’, ‘Pain’, ‘Anguish’, ‘Agony’ – mere words could not capture the absolute emptiness one felt on witnessing such inhumanity.

On one side was the pain of the victims of the earthquake, and on the other the pain of the victims of the riots. In decisively confronting this great turmoil, I had to single-mindedly focus all the strength given to me by the almighty, on the task of peace, justice and rehabilitation; burying the pain and agony I was personally wracked with.

During those challenging times, I often recollected the wisdom in our scriptures; explaining how those seating in positions of power did not have the right to share their own pain and anguish. They had to suffer it in solitude. I lived through the same,experiencing this anguish in searingly sharp intensity. In fact, whenever I remember those agonizing days, I have only one earnest prayer to God. That never again should such cruelly unfortunate days come in the lives of any other person, society, state or nation.

This is the first time I am sharing the harrowing ordeal I had gone through in those days at a personal level.

However, it was from these very built up emotions that I had appealed to the people of Gujarat on the day of the Godhra train burning itself; fervently urging for peace and restraint to ensure lives of innocents were not put at risk. I had repeatedly reiterated the same principles in my daily interactions with the media in those fateful days of February-March 2002 as well; publically underlining the political will as well as moral responsibility of the government to ensure peace, deliver justice and punish all guilty of violence. You will also find these deep emotions in my recent words at my Sadbhavana fasts, where I had emphasized how such deplorable incidents did not behove a civilized society and had pained me deeply.

In fact, my emphasis has always been on developing and emphasizing a spirit of unity; with the now widely used concept of ‘my 5 crore Gujarati brothers and sisters’ having crystallised right at the beginning of my tenure as CM itself from this very space.

However, as if all the suffering was not enough, I was also accused of the death and misery of my own loved ones, my Gujarati brothers and sisters. Can you imagine the inner turmoil and shock of being blamed for the very events that have shattered you!

For so many years, they incessantly kept up their attack, leaving no stone unturned. What pained even more was that in their overzealousness to hit at me for their narrow personal and political ends, they ended up maligning my entire state and country. This heartlessly kept reopening the wounds that we were sincerely trying to heal. It ironically also delayed the very justice that these people claimed to be fighting for. Maybe they did not realize how much suffering they were adding to an already pained people.

Gujarat however had decided its own path. We chose peace over violence. We chose unity over divisiveness. We chose goodwill over hatred. This was not easy, but we were determined to commit for the long haul. From a life of daily uncertainty and fear; my Gujarat transformed into one of Shanti, Ekta and Sadbhavana. I stand a satisfied and reassured man today. And for this, I credit each and every Gujarati.

The Gujarat Government had responded to the violence more swiftly and decisively than ever done before in any previous riots in the country. Yesterday’s judgement culminated a process of unprecedented scrutiny closely monitored by the highest court of the land, the Honourable Supreme Court of India. Gujarat’s 12 years of trial by the fire have finally drawn to an end. I feel liberated and at peace.

I am truly grateful to all those who stood by me in these trying times; seeing through the facade of lies and deceit. With this cloud of misinformation firmly dispelled, I will now also hope that the many others out there trying to understand and connect with the real Narendra Modi would feel more empowered to do so.

Those who derive satisfaction by perpetuating pain in others will probably not stop their tirade against me. I do not expect them to. But, I pray in all humility, that they at least now stop irresponsibly maligning the 6 crore people of Gujarat.

Emerging from this journey of pain and agony; I pray to God that no bitterness seeps into my heart. I sincerely do not see this judgement as a personal victory or defeat, and urge all – my friends and especially my opponents – to not do so as well. I was driven by this same principle at the time of the Honourable Supreme Court’s 2011 judgement on this matter. I fasted 37 days for Sadbhavana, choosing to translate the positive judgement into constructive action, reinforcing Unity and Sadbhavana in society at large.

I am deeply convinced that the future of any society, state or country lies in harmony. This is the only foundation on which progress and prosperity can be built. Therefore, I urge one and all to join hands in working towards the same, ensuring smiles on each and every face. Once again, Satyameva Jayate! Vande Mataram!

[May check, Gujarat riots 2002: Was wracked with pain, says Narendra Modi, by FP Staff Dec 27, 2013.

I think, political scientists might analyze this tweet for a good length of time to decide whether it is a true confession or a classic piece of a clever politician's pseudo remorse. As they will focus more attention on the contemporary situation and the impending general elections, they might not bother much about Mr. Modi's antecedent actions and utterances. But, historians might take a different view and try to assess him as a politician in toto. 
For a mere nobody in Indian politics, like me, who only follows it as an existential engagement, a time-pass, and never as a stake-holder, the question is rather of only academic interest. But it is a real question all the same: 
Is the tweet proof of a changed Mr. Modi? Or, an yet another instance of a politician's double speak? The jury is still out. Let us not rush it. 
Whatever the verdict, Mr. Modi is likely to go down in history as the most successful Indian demagogue ever, perhaps next only to Mr. Jayaprakash Narayan. Those who follow history might see a pattern in the career of demagogues. Be that as it is. I take solace in the fairly familiar adage; Sambhavami yuge yuge ....

Tuesday, December 24, 2013

Historians are mightier than God!

Not even God can change the Past. But historians can! Because, they are the Creators of the past!
A post and a response.
On Sun, Dec 22, 2013 at 9:15 PM, Drmaruthur <drmaruthur@gmail.com> wrote:
My Life

Life is a dream. We don't know where we came from except some may say, we are born into the world. Only beings who say. we are born, are the beings already in the dream. Then we go on in a dream-living as though it is real.  In this dream we feel things as real because of our 'senses'  which includes the brain. We really cannot explain how senses and brain do their THINGS. Then we dream during the day and night. The day dreams are persistent and appreciated by all the brings in their own dream. ( a group dream) Then we disappear and only the beings in their dream feel we are dead ( disappeared). The person who died dies not know it. Anyway our individual dreams has ended. In our night dream we don't know we fall asleep and dream another set of life events which are as real as the 'real' life while you are sleeping. Then we wake up to our 'waking dreams' to live another day. The beings  include the whole universe.

We try to explain our dreams with thoughts (dreams), words, numbers, concepts and ideas. We have written books using dream words based in dream thoughts. And a lot of theories, theory of this and that in the physical realm.  But they are also dreams. If we deeply dream about it, we have no real existence. In the metaphysical level we have religious scriptures which we have created by men. Nobody has any real life ideas yet, but may have dreamy hallucinations about our birth, death and creations. (Including God and gods and done people no god, etc) I have no idea how that explains life. But I don't get it. This is how I ( me- this dreamer) feel about it. I wish I could fall into everybody's dream and enjoy life better.




Sent from my iPhone
8:17 PM (9 hours ago)

My response:

On Dec 24, 2013, at 12:00 AM, "Sudhakaran P.P." <sudhakaranpp@gmail.com> wrote:
Just a random response, as vacuous as a response can ever be!

Any philosophical discourse, which is what your posts really are, can be from a personal or from a universal stand point. "Life is a dream", "We do not know" and the like, incidentally, have the form of universal statements. That is the attraction many may find in your posts.

The other is the personal viewpoint. 

All universal statements, if in a public domain, are liable to be ignored, endorsed, challenged or disputed. Critical readers generally challenge or dispute. That is why one wisecrack is alleged to have said, 'For every philosopher there shall be an equal and opposite philosopher!' 

Personal beliefs and convictions, on the other hand, are usually left alone. They are invariably just untested opinions floated for responses, or left in a limbo for no better options. By convention they are qualified explicitly or implicitly with an 'I think' or 'I believe'. 

Readers follow personal opinions for different reasons. Some read out of curiosity about the person behind the posts. Some, who are generally serious, read looking for ideas resonating with their own. 

But, when a personal opinion is presented from a universal standpoint, there are bound to be problems. Of course, for the readers! These problems are compounded when the ideas expressed are abstract. 

A good example for an abstract idea is dream. It may be true that we dream, but what we dream or think we dreamt are not real. Needless to say, one cannot dream another's dream, that is, unless one is in Alice's Wonderland. The dreamer himself cannot be sure about whether he dreamt or what he dreamt. Such a terribly personal, virtual, fleeting and little understood experience can never be a universal denominator. If I say, 'Life is a dream', it will convey precious little by way of meaning. The question is not whether you are right or I am right or anyone is right. 

Not that you do not know these. Still, I thought I would just respond to this post of yours.

Wish you a warrm, happy Christmas

His Response:
Your response is more dreamy than my post on life   That is good. I have put your response on FB without mentioning ur name.

Sent from my iPhone

  

  



Want to test your psychopathic nature or potential? You MAY take this test, courtesy an Oxford Professor:
 http://psychopath.channel4.com/quizzes.html#test2

I could score only 6%! Clever me!

Saturday, November 23, 2013

How To Fix Your PC0 the Right Way Gizmodo

Most of the common problems of a PC can be solved at the user level following this GIZMODO compilation. Keep it, preferably outside your PC. And beware the spectre of Murphy's Law!
Please go to http://gizmodo.com/how-to-fix-your-pc-the-right-way-1468221892  

Friday, November 22, 2013

Historians are angry with Narendra Modi

Narendra Modi’s history bloomers became news obviously because he is trying to sell himself as an invincible super-politician. As it is election season, his detractors gleefully lampooned him. They made it appear that he would recklessly bluff about things he did not know.

But, the grievance of a historian would be different. History has only very few facts to hold on to, namely, dates of events and names of people and places. That is the stuff largely of elementary class history. Everything else in its vast corpus is interpretation or perception; just gas that is usually dealt with at higher levels. Here, Modi has failed in elementary history! That is unpardonable in an aspiring PM of India.

Saturday, November 02, 2013

Tired of your intrusive net accounts, like the Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin and Google+? Here is help, thanks to Andrew Tarantola on Gizmodo:
http://www.gizmodo.in/news/How-to-Erase-Yourself-From-the-Internet/articleshow/25140190.cms

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Aadhaar and the cobwebs

The Editorial, “Voluntarily mandatory” (The Hindu, Sept. 30, 2013), explaining what is voluntary and what is mandatory in the Aadhaar programme was very helpful. This is a point that was generally missed in public discussions of the programme.

         Instead of keeping the mandatory National Population Registration and the voluntary Unique ID Numbering separate, the UIDAI confused the people with the overt and covert support of a number of government agencies that they were a single programme. Many obviously believed that without the Aadhaar number they would miss various subsidies and services; that they would lose even their citizenship even if they possessed other identity proofs. The long queues in front of Aadhaar registration centres were formed by those who were evidently anxious about this threat. After the Supreme Court clearing the air and after spending thousands of crores of rupees, what the UIDAI will do next is worth watching.

NOTA, Mr. L.K.Advani and compulsory voting

A Letter to the Editor

NOTA and compulsory voting
Sir,
         In seeking to relate NOTA to compulsory voting as a “meaningful” requirement, Mr. Advani’s blog has completely missed its meaning. By allowing the right to reject, the Supreme Court has actually enlarged the choice of the voter. Mr. Advani wants to restrict it, ignoring the fact that democracy is all about voluntariness in political choices. Right to vote is an inalienable right vested in the voter, which includes also the right not to vote. Making it mandatory would give the establishment an opportunity to coerce the voters and punish the defaulters.
         That Mr. Advani has endorsed Mr. Modi’s idea is not surprising, for, both are products of an organization that upholds discipline, regimentation and uniformity in matter even of culture as virtues. There could be one more reason. The inspiration for launching the BJP in 1980 was the hope that the Hindus, being the majority community, would put the Party in power in perpetuity. Mr. Advani, perhaps, hopes now that at least when driven into the polling booths, a sufficiently large number of Hindus might always choose the ‘Hindutva’ party.

Friday, October 04, 2013

Who owns the alphabet?

Who owns the alphabet, of any language for that matter, but now, of English? Here is an interesting case.

Recently, Exxon Mobile filed a lawsuit Tuesday, 1 October, in the U.S. District Court in Houston, challenging the 21st Century Fox’s trademark registration and seeking an injunction against using the logo FXX. It also sought triple damages for the harm it suffered from the resulting confusion in the 'market'.

It complained that FXX, when contacted directly, refused either to stop using or to remove the interlocking FXX design. Hence the petition.

Among other things, it argued that it was likely to “cause confusion, to cause mistake, or to deceive customers and potential customers.” It feared that, if not constrained, FXX might be mistaken for an affiliate of Exxon. In support, it cited some posts on the web, like "That FXX logo has to go, that is awful on a plate. Also, Exxon is going to be pissed.” A spokesman for ExxonMobil claimed that the “public associates the interlocking Xs with ‘Exxon’ and ‘ExxonMobil,’ and they represent a valuable part of our branding. ExxonMobil has protected its interlocking-X designs with numerous trademark registrations, and has been using its interlocking Xs both alone and as part of ExxonMobil’s distinctive family of ‘Exxon’ and ‘ExxonMobil’ marks for decades.”

FXX is an American TV network doing entertainment business, a David when compared.to the Goliath Exxon, which is world's richest oil company. A spokesperson of FXX asked whether a consumer ever approach FXX for oil or Exxon for a TV serial?

As David Sirota (a nationally syndicated newspaper columnist, magazine journalist and the author of the books "Hostile Takeover," "The Uprising" and "Back to Our Future" E-mail him at ds@davidsirota.com,), would put it: "Apparently if you are the world’s richest oil company used to making $104 million in profit every day, no lawsuit is too frivolous, expensive or downright hilarious when you are the plaintiff."

In essence, Exxon wants exclusive world rights to put two Xs next to each other. Lone X does not belong to it, Three or more Xs also are no problem, for now at least. Whether its lawsuit covers also the Xs in all other non-Latin alphabets, the mathematical symbol for multiplication or any symbol in any other script resembling X,  is not clear.

There already are logos containing double X, like that of Dos Equisll. As Sirota asks: 'what about the XX chromosome, and the roman numeral for 20, and any clothing companies that make T-shirts marked double extra large'.

According to Sirota, 'ExxonMobil’s suit instantly makes it a candidate for the list of the most famous intellectual property claims of all time.' Among instances he quotes are:

"- Spike Lee claiming exclusive ownership rights of his first name in a suit against Viacom’s Spike TV.

- Fox News being laughed out of court after claiming exclusive ownership of the phrase “fair and balanced.”

- Warner/Chappell Music arguing in court that the 120-year-old “Happy Birthday” song is its exclusive property.

- Huey Lewis suing Ray Parker Jr. over allegations that the latter’s “Ghostbusters” anthem resembled the former’s “I Want a New Drug.”

- Larrikin Music suing Men at Work for damages, based on the company’s claims that the music group’s flute in the song “Down Under” derives from a 75-year-old children’s song called “Kookaburra Sits in the Old Gum Tree.” The music company claiming the rights to the Kookaburra song didn’t file suit until 28 years after Men at Work’s hit was released. That’s when a television quiz show in Australia claimed there was a resemblance between the two tunes."

Whether intellectual property is protectable is a moot question. Even if we concede that stealing intellectual property is a serious crime, Sirota says that 'many of the aforementioned suits — including ExxonMobil’s — seem more than a bit absurd.' He reminds us that the U.S. Supreme Court has recently ratified the right of companies to claim patent protections for DNA. May be, as he says, in the brave new world of intellectual property, “absurd” is apparently in the eye of the beholder!

To put it mildly, the intellectual property right issue is a bit bizarre. If I buy a house, I can do whatever I want with it, but not if it is a book. I can buy a kidney, and it will become my exclusive property. Neither its donor nor the surgeon who transplanted it has no right over it. But, in the case of a book, even its printer/ publisher can own its intellectual property rights. An original work of art can be bought and owned exclusively, but not a book. One can understand the claim of IPR for the original manuscript as long it is not sold, but even after it is printed in thousands and sold, each of the copies also carry copy right! In that case, should not the author himself and the printer/publisher be sued first for forging copies of an original work?

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Dr. Kumar wrote:
There is no opposite to any thing that is truly real ....

What is the opposite of love, many will say is hate. But that is at mind level. 
But at the no-mind level, say heart level, there is no opposite to love.

LOVE IS JUST LOVE.
LIFE IS JUST LIFE.
BEAUTY IS JUST BEAUTY.
GOODNESS IS JUST GOODNESS.

No opposite unless we start using our all very 'useful utilitarian' MIND.

I responded:
Please leave this dead horse alone! Emotions, like tastes, why, even genders, are not in binary opposite relationships. Assuming first that they are, and then flogging the very same assumption was a pastime for the Sophists. It is a verbal labyrinth, a trap. No one will dispute that 'life is life', and if one wants to stay put at that level, quite fine for her or him. But, why grudge somebody who thinks life has various attributes and tries to understand and explain them? Further, how will one ever use a word without knowing what it means. Definitions, explanations, synonyms and antonyms - knowing what a word means or does not mean - are integral to understanding anything. Dismissing all that as the delusion of the mind is a pointless denial. There is one character in the VKN novel, 'One Week', one Electric Thoma, whose vocabulary in English was limited to less than a hundred words. For anything he did not know the proper word for, he would use 'that corner'! Think of a physician who tells all and every patient of his with running temperature - 'a fever is only a fever, take aspirin'! Such thinking is usually called 'reductio ad absurdum'. Indian philosophy for ages, starting with Upanishads, also has held this 'funnel' vision of the world. In human affairs, there are no perfect antonyms or synonyms. So, let us stop flogging a dead horse!